• ×

    The Truth About Oscar’s Reality-Based Films

    In the first 72 years of the Academy Awards (1927-99), 14 fact-based movies won the best-picture prize, or 19%. In the 21st century, fact-based films have won 33% of the time.

    Last year, three of 2018’s four acting winners (Rami Malik, Olivia Colman, Mahershala Ali) were playing real-life characters. And six of the eight best-picture contenders were fact-based, including winner “Green Book.”

    For whatever reasons, based-on-reality films are clearly increasing, and are increasingly finding favor from awards-givers. At the same time, there has also been a boost in a sub-category: the autobiographical film. Last year’s “Roma” fit into that category and the auto-truth group has multiplied this year.

    In 2019 there have been so many reality-based tales that it’s possible (but unlikely) that every Oscar nominee will be from a fact-based film. In alphabetical order, the list includes “The Aeronauts,” “A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood,” “Bombshell,” “Dark Waters,” “Dolemite Is My Name,” “Ford v Ferrari,” “Harriet,” “A Hidden Life,” “The Irishman,” “Judy,” “Just Mercy,” “The Laundromat,” “Midway,” “The Report,” “Richard Jewell,” “Rocketman,” “Seberg,” “Skin” and “The Two Popes.”

    In terms of autobiographical films, the list includes “Honey Boy,” “The Farewell” and possibly “Marriage Story.” (Noah Baumbach has always stated that “Marriage” is not autobiographical, though mainstream media persist in underlining parallels to the director’s life.)

    Popular on Variety

    Colleagues and critics have pointed out autobiographical elements in Sony Pictures Classics’ Pedro Almodóvar movie “Pain and Glory,” about a film director coming to terms with himself and his past. Antonio Banderas, a likely Oscar contender for his portrayal of the director, offers observations that apply to all fact-based films.

    “Sometimes we would ask Almodovar ‘Did this really happen?’ and he would say, ‘Yes, it happened in my mind, so it happened.’ Some events definitely occurred in his life; others are moments he would have loved to say and do, but didn’t. We are not only what happens in our lives, we are also the things we dreamed. In a way, this movie is more Almodóvar than the real Almodóvar.

    “He was so emotionally attached to some scenes he wrote, that before filming them, I received non-verbal emotional indications that I could use immediately. I would look at him and say ‘I got it! Don’t talk, just say “action!” I know what this scene is about.’ I don’t know if I will ever have that kind of experience again.”

    Banderas adds with a little laugh, “What are the odds I will ever again in my lifetime be directed by my own character?”

    Under Hollywood’s studio system, writer-directors were rare, and they couldn’t make autobiographical films. But filmmakers overseas and in the indie world, ranging from Ingmar Bergman and Jean-Luc Godard to John Cassavetes, used personal elements in many films.

    Since then, the list has become longer and more diverse, including Francois Truffaut’s “The 400 Blows,” Sam Fuller’s “The Big Red One,” George Lucas’ “American Graffiti,” Bob Fosse’s “All That Jazz,” Terence Davies’ “Distant Voices, Still Lives,” Greta Gerwig’s “Lady Bird” and Marjane Satrapi’s “Persepolis,” to mention a few.

    Federico Fellini, whose autobiographical films include “I Vitelloni,” “8½” and “Amarcord,” addressed the logic of this in a 1965 interview with Atlantic Monthly. He said, “All art is autobiographical. The pearl is the oyster’s autobiography.”

    As for the flood of fact-based films, it’s become an annual ritual for bloggers and the media to point out, usually with horror, how each film differs from reality. Sometimes the shaming comes from Oscar rivals trying to denigrate a front-runner; sometimes it’s from non-industry types trying to get a name for themselves.

    These criticisms are about niggling details that don’t matter: One character in “Green Book” did not teach the other how to enjoy fried chicken, we don’t know that Queen Anne in “The Favourite” said such things, “Vice” omitted some incidents in Dick Cheney’s life, etc. Bottom line: These are just nitpicking.

    Shakespeare played fast and loose with the truth in many plays, including “Julius Caesar” and “Richard III.” And those plays hold up quite nicely, thanks.

    From “The Great Ziegfeld” and “The Life of Emile Zola” through “The Sound of Music,” “A Beautiful Mind” and “Argo,” Oscar voters have embraced fact-based movies that took huge liberties with the facts. A fact-based film doesn’t have to be factually correct, but it has to be emotionally honest.

    Quentin Tarantino is upfront about fiddling with facts for “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.” A filmmaker always has artistic license to omit or include certain things. But Tarantino does something different. He takes incidents that are well known, and that affected many lives, and he changes them. His choices are odd and troubling; as Variety critic Owen Gleiberman observed, it’s the movie equivalent of fake news. Yet many people love the film and are not bothered by this. Hm.

    As you study the reality of this year’s contenders, don’t obsess over the small details of “accuracy.” Just appreciate the pearls.

    More Film

    • Australia' s Oscar contender BuoyancyC

      Trafficking Tale ‘Buoyancy’ Heads For North American Release at Kino Lorber

      “Buoyancy,” the Australian-made story that has gathered momentum as a powerhouse depiction of human trafficking, is set to be released in North American theaters. Rights were acquired by specialty distributor Kino Lorber, which will give it a cinema opening in Spring 2020 ahead of video on demand and home video outings. The rights sale was [...]

    • Charles Randolph Amazon

      Film News Roundup: 'Bombshell' Writer Charles Randolph Tapped for Writers Guild Honor

      In today’s film news roundup, “Bombshell” writer Charles Randolph and production designers William J. Creber and Roland Anderson are set for honors and Abrams Agency opens a London office. AWARD WINNERS Charles Randolph  has been named the recipient of the Writers Guild of America West’s 2020 Paul Selvin Award in recognition of his script for [...]

    • Weathering With You Japanese Anima

      Global Hit Toon 'Weathering With You' Signals Climate Change for Japanese Anime

      Makoto Shinkai’s “Weathering With You,” which tells the tale of a young boy who falls for a girl with the power to stop ceaseless rainstorms pounding Tokyo, marks the first time an anime has been chosen as Japan’s foreign-language Oscar entry.  The GKIDS release echoes an element of Shinkai’s previous anime, “Your Name,” a body-swapping story that was [...]

    • Victoria BBC

      Small Nation, Big Reach: The U.K. Exerts Outsize Influence in the World of Entertainment

      The sun never sets on the British entertainment empire. Whether it’s the BBC’s “Blue Planet II” wowing TV viewers in Beijing or Paddington Bear’s new movie making kids squeal in Bulgaria or the latest West End hit thrilling theater buffs on Broadway, Britain’s cultural offerings have conquered consumers the world over. Like the U.K.’s diplomatic prowess [...]

    • Harvey Weinsteinopening arguments

      Harvey Weinstein Trial: Opening Arguments on Schedule to Start Next Week

      The Harvey Weinstein trial has already seen its share of pyrotechnics. The defense asked last week for a new judge — denied — and for more time to question the prospective jurors, which included, of all people, model Gigi Hadid. But despite the distractions, opening arguments are still on course to begin next week, Variety has [...]

    • Parasite

      How to Watch This Year's Oscar-Nominated Films

      The 2020 Oscar nominations have been announced, and if you are looking to catch up on the most this season’s most talked-about films — such as “Joker” and “Parasite” — before the awards show, we’ve gathered up the best ways to watch or stream all the original films, documentaries, and animated shorts competing this season. [...]

    More From Our Brands

    Access exclusive content